That's Not How You Do It, Manhwa: A Deep Dive into Genre Conventions and Expectations
The world of manhwa, Korean comics, has exploded in popularity, captivating audiences with diverse storylines and unique artistic styles. However, many readers, especially those new to the genre, often find themselves frustrated by certain narrative choices, leading to the common complaint, "That's not how you do it, manhwa!" This statement highlights the specific expectations and conventions that readers have come to associate with the genre, and when these are broken, it can lead to a jarring experience. This article delves into the common tropes and expectations within manhwa, exploring why certain narrative choices resonate – or fail to resonate – with readers.
What Makes Manhwa Unique?
Before addressing the "That's not how you do it" critique, it's crucial to understand what sets manhwa apart. Many manhwa, especially those within the romance, fantasy, and action genres, often rely on certain stylistic and narrative choices:
-
Intense Character Design: Manhwa frequently features highly stylized character designs with exaggerated features, vibrant colors, and dramatic expressions. This contributes to the emotional impact and visual storytelling.
-
Fast-Paced Storytelling: Many manhwa prioritize quick plot progression, focusing on impactful moments and leaving less room for extensive world-building or character development in comparison to other mediums.
-
Dramatic Plot Twists and Reveals: Unexpected turns of events and shocking revelations are common, often serving as major plot drivers and keeping readers engaged.
-
Power Fantasies and Wish Fulfillment: Many manhwa cater to power fantasies, placing the protagonist in extraordinary situations with abilities or opportunities that readers might wish for themselves.
Why Do Readers Criticize Manhwa? Common Complaints Explained
The "That's not how you do it" criticism often stems from several recurring issues:
1. Inconsistent Worldbuilding and Logic: Some manhwa prioritize exciting plot developments over internal consistency. This can manifest as inconsistencies in established rules, unexplained plot devices, or illogical character behavior. Readers may find these inconsistencies jarring and detract from their enjoyment.
2. Overused Tropes and Clichés: The manhwa genre, like any other, employs certain recurring themes and plot devices. However, overuse of familiar tropes, especially without creative twists or reinterpretations, can lead to predictable and unoriginal storylines. This can result in the feeling that a manhwa fails to deliver on its potential.
3. Unrealistic Character Development: While many manhwa emphasize dramatic moments, rapid plot progression can sometimes overshadow character depth and believable development. Characters might undergo abrupt personality shifts or make decisions that are out of character, frustrating readers invested in their journey.
4. Weak Pacing and Info Dumping: While a fast-paced narrative can be engaging, some manhwa might fall into the trap of excessive exposition or "info-dumping," overwhelming the reader with large chunks of background information all at once instead of integrating it organically into the narrative.
How Can Manhwa Improve?
Addressing the criticisms requires a nuanced understanding of the genre's strengths and weaknesses. Here are some ways manhwa creators can elevate their work:
-
Prioritize Internal Consistency: Carefully crafting a believable world with consistent rules and logic is crucial for long-term reader engagement.
-
Subvert Tropes, Don't Just Repeat Them: While familiar tropes can provide a foundation, skillful writers can utilize them in unique and unexpected ways to create compelling narratives.
-
Focus on Believable Character Development: Characters should evolve organically, driven by internal motivations and consistent behavior.
-
Integrate Worldbuilding Seamlessly: Instead of overwhelming the reader with large chunks of information, gradually reveal details through natural storytelling.
Conclusion: The Ongoing Evolution of Manhwa
The statement "That's not how you do it, manhwa" points to a desire for improvement within the genre. While many manhwa succeed in delivering compelling narratives, others stumble due to inconsistent world-building, reliance on clichés, or underdeveloped characters. By focusing on consistency, innovation, and believable character arcs, manhwa creators can continue to captivate audiences and push the boundaries of the genre. The future of manhwa lies in its ability to meet the evolving expectations of its dedicated readership.
