Is Mosaic's "The Complete Capitol Recordings of Duke Ellington" Worth Purchasing?
Duke Ellington's legacy as a jazz giant is undeniable. His vast and varied catalog is a treasure trove for music lovers, and the Capitol recordings represent a significant period in his prolific career. But is Mosaic's meticulously compiled box set, "The Complete Capitol Recordings of Duke Ellington," worth the considerable investment? Let's delve into this question, exploring various aspects to help you decide.
What's Included in the Mosaic Box Set?
This isn't just any compilation. The Mosaic box set boasts an impressive collection encompassing everything Ellington recorded for Capitol Records, meticulously restored and remastered. We're talking about numerous albums, previously unreleased outtakes, and alternate takes—a truly comprehensive archive of Ellington's work during a specific and important era. The sheer volume of music alone makes it a compelling proposition for serious Ellington enthusiasts. The quality of the remastering is also frequently praised for bringing out the richness and detail of the original recordings.
Is it Worth the Price?
This is the big question, and the answer depends entirely on your priorities and budget. The set's price point is undoubtedly high, reflecting the extensive work involved in its production, the rarity of some included material, and the high-quality packaging. For casual listeners or those with limited budgets, it might be an extravagant purchase. However, for serious collectors, Ellington aficionados, or those seeking an unparalleled listening experience of a significant period in his career, the value proposition is much stronger. The sheer volume of previously unavailable material and the superior sound quality often justify the cost for dedicated fans.
What are the Alternatives?
If the Mosaic box set is beyond your reach, there are still plenty of ways to enjoy Ellington's Capitol recordings. Individual albums are readily available through various digital and physical retailers. This allows for a more budget-friendly approach, letting you cherry-pick the albums most appealing to you. However, you'll miss out on the comprehensive nature and superior sound quality offered by the Mosaic set.
What makes this box set special compared to other Ellington releases?
The Mosaic set distinguishes itself through its unparalleled completeness. It meticulously gathers all recordings from a specific period, including previously unreleased tracks and alternate takes. This degree of comprehensiveness is rarely found in other Ellington releases, offering a truly in-depth look at his work within this specific timeframe. The superior audio restoration also adds significantly to the listening experience.
Are there any downsides to the Mosaic Box Set?
The main downside, as already mentioned, is the price. Its high cost makes it inaccessible to many. Additionally, while the sheer volume of music is impressive, it might feel overwhelming to some listeners. It requires a significant time commitment to fully appreciate the entire collection.
Final Verdict:
The Mosaic "Complete Capitol Recordings of Duke Ellington" is not a purchase to be taken lightly. Its price is substantial, and it's geared towards dedicated collectors and serious Ellington fans. If you're passionate about his work and are looking for an exhaustive and impeccably remastered collection, the value is likely worth the investment. However, if you're a casual listener or have budget constraints, exploring individual albums or digital releases might be a more suitable option. Ultimately, the decision rests on your personal appreciation for Ellington's music and your financial considerations.
